Posted on 14 September 2010.
Scarlette Harris, Reporter
As debate rises in New York City over the development of a Muslim community center, a religious community struggles to keep its respect and reputation. According to other news sources, the new facility, called Park 51, will be two blocks away from Ground Zero. Park 51 will contain a pool, recreational center, bookstore, auditorium, restaurant, and a mosque. The controversy is how people see the Muslim world.
Amna Adrees, a practicing Muslim and a WHS student, wants to show people what Islam really is, and that it is not a terrorist religion.
“The main misconception is, with this Ground Zero mosque, is that 9/11 was caused by Islam, which is not really true because it was just an extremist group that didn’t know about the basics of Islam anyway. Terrorists don’t really have a religion because they’re terrorists… religion’s purpose is to be good and help people, and not hurt anyone,” Adrees said.
One of the main reasons why some Americans are against the mosque is because of recent conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan and especially from what happened in 9/11. However, according to Shahnaz Adrees, Amna’s mother, in the Holy Quran, there is a verse that states if a person kills another, it is like killing all of humanity. There is no terrorism in Islam, Shahnaz Adrees said.
Also, some people aren’t educated in the beliefs of the religion. Amna shared a story about her father’s business. A Christian church raised an issue and spoke out about the fact that Adrees’s father owned a gas station nearby. At the same time, people stood up to say that such persecution was inappropriate and unfair. It might have hurt the business, Amna said, because some of the audience might have actually listened to the false facts.
“A lot of people listen to what they’re told; I guess that’s not very good.”
While critics say Park 51 would be disrespectful to those who were killed on 9/11, and that it’s too close to the Ground Zero site, Amna disagrees. She said that the location might not have anything to do with Ground Zero; it just might be a coincidence that it is two blocks away.
“We don’t really know the factors that went into them getting that area; if it was cheaper… you can’t really say that’s because of the location exactly. It is two blocks away, it’s not at Ground Zero,” Amna said.
Muslim Americans also died at the World Trade Center, she pointed out. “Would it be disrespectful to them if the mosque weren’t built at all?”
According to the Park 51 website (www.park51.org), the location of the center was considered because of the space it has for crowds, and that it was easily accessible for people from Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Staten Island. Also, the site states that it would be of help to the surrounding neighborhood and that the community board that represented the neighborhood gave unanimous consent to the project being built.
Shahnaz Adrees adds that in Islam, if a mosque provides an inconvenience to the surrounding area, then it should not be built. There shouldn’t be any problems within the community despite the fact that Park 51 is a particular center under lots of heat.
Amna said she would have no problem with actually going to the center.
“I would go, why not? What’s wrong about going to a mosque as a Muslim? It’s the same as someone who is a Christian visiting New York going to a church. It doesn’t matter.”
Amna said she hopes that the violence will go down if the mosque is built because of the safety of those that live in New York, including some of her family members. Recently, there was a taxi driver in New York who was stabbed when answering he was Muslim to a passenger’s question.
“If you look at the ideal then I would want it to be built, but I feel it might cause more trouble than necessary,” Amna said. “Religion isn’t supposed to be violent, and a mosque is supposed to be for people to go pray and relax…it’s for us to do our thing…I don’t think it would be the Muslims’ fault if it caused violence. It is people not realizing the reasoning behind it being built.”
The right to religious freedom is one of the main arguments of those who agree with Park 51 being built. That’s one of the main reasons why Adrees wants it to be built.
“When you think of Americans you shouldn’t think about a religion, you should think about citizens.” Amna said. “We’re all Americans; it doesn’t matter if we’re Christians or Jews or Muslims or Hindus, or whatever because we’re all living here together, so religion shouldn’t even be an issue. That’s the point of America.”
Whether Park 51 is built or not, Adrees and her mother want to show people what their religion is really like. In English they said, Islam translates into “submission,” which comes from the word that means “peace.”